Revitalization of The Spirit of Rule of Law: A Critical Reflection on The Dynamics of Democracy in Indonesia

Authors

  • Achmad Yazid Bistomi Kalijaga State Islamic University Author
  • Hasmaryadi Hasmaryadi Kalijaga State Islamic University Author
  • Ahmad Fauzi Kalijaga State Islamic University Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.62710/zg6y4993

Keywords:

Rule Of Law, Democracy, Constitutional State Legal Reform Substantive Democracy

Abstract

This study is motivated by the declining quality of democracy in Indonesia, reflected in the weakening independence of law enforcement institutions, shrinking civic space, limited public participation in policymaking, and the growing influence of political oligarchies over legal and governmental processes. These developments demonstrate a widening gap between the constitutional ideals of the rule of law and the realities of contemporary democratic governance. This research aims to critically examine the relationship between the rule of law and Indonesia's democratic dynamics while formulating strategies to revitalize the spirit of the rule of law as a foundation for strengthening substantive democracy. The study employs normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, and philosophical approaches, supported by analyses of empirical indicators, scholarly literature, and reports from national and international institutions. The findings reveal that democratic regression is driven not only by weak law enforcement but also by political intervention in state institutions, non-participatory legislative processes, restrictions on civil liberties, and the dominance of oligarchic interests in public policymaking. Consequently, revitalizing the spirit of the rule of law requires strengthening judicial and institutional independence, reforming democratic law-making processes, expanding meaningful public participation, and fostering a legal culture grounded in accountability, constitutional supremacy, and the protection of human rights. These measures are essential to restoring public trust and advancing a more just, accountable, and sustainable democratic system in Indonesia.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

  • Achmad Yazid Bistomi, Kalijaga State Islamic University

    Islamic Law, Faculty of Sharia and Law

  • Hasmaryadi Hasmaryadi, Kalijaga State Islamic University

    Islamic Law, Faculty of Sharia and Law

  • Ahmad Fauzi, Kalijaga State Islamic University

    Islamic Law, Faculty of Sharia and Law

References

Abdullah, A. (2025). Legal Reform in the Grip of Oligarchy: Tracing the Gap Between Constitutional Legitimacy and Elite Interests. Serambi Hukum Research Journal, 18(01), 85–100. Https://Doi.Org/10.59582/Sh.V18i01.1353

Aeni, A. N., Sundari, C. E., & Saputra, R. (2023). Community Participation in Political Understanding Regarding Preparations for the 2024 Election. Abdi Bhara, 2(1). (2023): 99-108 DOI : Https://Doi.Org/10.31599/Abhara.V2i1.2472.

Agustino, L., Sylviana, M., & Andalus, M. K. (2022). Executive Aggrandisement and Democratic Regression in Indonesia’s Jokowi Administration. Jispo: Journal of Social and Political Sciences, 12, 245–271. Https://Journal.Uinsgd.Ac.Id/

Asyikin, N., & Setiawan, A. (2020). The Position of the KPK in the State Constitutional System Following the Enactment of the KPK Law Revision. Justitia Law Journal, 4(1). (2020): 130-131. Https://Doi.Org/10.30651/Justitia.V4i1.3736.

Birkenkötter, H., & Burchardt, D. (2025). The Rule Of Law In Germany: Bringing The Rechtsstaat Into The 21st Century. Hart Publishing. The Rule Of Law In Context, Volume 3. Hart Publishing, 2025. 216 P. - The Rule Of Law In Context - ISBN: 9781509969272 - Permalink: Https://Digital.Casalini.It/9781509969272 - Casalini Id: 6036018

Damanik, E. R., Farina, T., & Nugraha, S. (2025). The Crisis of Public Participation in Legislation Formation in Indonesia: Issues Regarding Constitutional Rights and the Disregard for the People's Aspirations. Innovative: Journal of Social Science Research, 5(2), 2518–2540. Https://Doi.Org/10.31004/Innovative.V5i2.18664

Dicey, A. V. (1885). Lectures Introductory To The Study Of The Law Of The Constitution. London: Macmillan 1885: 110.

Fadillah, R. (2025). The Controversy Surrounding the Revision of the TNI Law from a Pancasila Perspective: A Study on Governance Implementation and Stakeholder Responses. Journal of Civic Education. 2025: 14.

Fatimah, S., Arif, M. Z., Day, G. S. S., & Zayyanurroihan, M. (2025). The Politics of House of Representatives (DPR) Rules of Procedure Regarding the Removal of Judges from the Constitutional Court, Supreme Court, and Corruption Eradication Commission, and the National Police Chief: An Analysis of Authority and Implications for the Independence of State Institutions. Wijaya Putra Law Review, 4(2), 217–242. Https://Doi.Org/10.38156/Wplr.V4i2.231

Fauzan Ramadhan, A. (2025). Law and Democracy: The Synergy Between the Rule of Law and Citizen Participation. Islamic Law: Jurnal Siyasah, 10(2), 192–202. https://doi.org/10.53429/iljs.v10i2.1814

Freedom House. (2025). Freedom In The World. Https://Freedomhouse.Org/Country/Indonesia/Freedom-World/2025

Gunawan, M. S. (2024). Reflections On The Implementation Of The Rule Of Law And Democracy In Indonesia. Jurnal Al Tasyri’iyyah, 4(1), 21–36. Https://Doi.Org/10.24252/Jat.V4i1.53910

Gustriani, W. S., Aswata, I., Arifin, F., & Rifqi, S. M. (2025). The Development of Constitutional Law from the Perspective of Democracy and the Rule of Law in Indonesia. Journal of Social Sciences and Science (Sosains), 5(9). (2025): 2781-2787.

Hakim, A. B., & Muhyidin, M. (2022). Democracy and High-Cost Politics. Josh: Journal of Sharia, 1(01), 12–22. Https://Doi.Org/10.55352/Josh.V1i1.149

Haliim, W., & Fatkhurrohman, M. (2025). Power Relations and Clientelism in the Political Culture of Indonesia's Poor: A Study of the Family Hope Program (PKH) Implementation. Journal of Government and Politics, 10(4), 688–705. Https://Doi.Org/10.36982/Jpp.V10i4.5965

Hanin Marwah. (2025). Amnesty International Indonesia Urges Government to Comprehensively Revise the ITE Law. https://www.tempo.co/hukum/amnesty-international-indonesia-desak-pemerintah-revisi-uu-ite-secara-menyeluruh-1303374

Hasan, R., Ticoalu, L. D., & Nur, A. A. A. (2025). Diorama Of The Directive Constitutional: Reconstruction Of Directive Constitutionalism And The Deliberative Crisis In Indonesia's Constitutional Democracy. Staatsrecht: Journal of State Law and Islamic Politics, 5(2). (2025): 430-457. Https://Doi.Org/10.14421/Staatsrecht.V5i2.4577

I Putu Nanda Pramudya & Wahyudi. (2025). Optimizing the Role of Law Enforcement Officials in Preventing Corruption in Indonesia. Naafi: Jurnal Ilmiah Mahasiswa, 1(6), 1003–1018. https://doi.org/10.62387/naafi.v1i6.318

Irwin, D., Erwiansyah, M. D., Khairullah, D., & Fartini, A. (2025). Constitutional Law Dynamics and Challenges to Democratic Practice in Indonesia: A Critical Study of Political Oligarchy and Electoral System Reform. Judge: Jurnal Hukum, 6(04), 1327–1338. https://doi.org/10.54209/judge.v6i04.1782

Jimly Asshiddiqie, S. (2021). Indonesia's Constitution and Constitutionalism. Sinar Grafika.46-48.

Lawrence M. Friedman,. (1975). The Legal System: A Social Science Perspective. Russell Sage Foundation, 1975.

Mahendra, Y. I. (2021). The Paradox of Democracy in Indonesia (2014–2019): A Procedural and Substantive Analysis. Paradigma Polistaat: Journal of Social and Political Sciences, 4(1), 27–47. https://doi.org/10.23969/paradigmapolistaat.v4i1.2214

Marzuq, M. S. (2025). Synergy Between The Rule Of Law And Pancasila Democracy In Guaranteeing Human Rights (Ham). Justices: Journal Of Law, 4(3), 193–199. Https://Doi.Org/10.58355/Justices.V4i3.187

Maulana, M. A., Maulida, R., Maghfiroh, S., & Viana, T. H. (2025). The Dynamics of the Evolution of Political Dynasties in Indonesia. Dekrit (Journal of Master of Laws), 70–92. Https://Ejournal.Fh.Ubhara.Ac.Id/Index.Php/Dekrit/Article/View/191

Nasoha, A. M. M., Atqiya, A. N., Khoiroh, Z. J., & Putri, R. D. A. (2025). The Relevance of Constitutionalism in Legislation Formation in Indonesia. Educational Harmony: Journal of Educational Sciences, 2(3), 202–215. Https://Doi.Org/10.62383/Hardik.V2i3.1812

Nurhakim, I., & Nurul Huda, U. (2025). The Politics of Election Law in Indonesia: A Shift from Rule by Law to Rule of Law within Political Configurations and Substantive Democracy. Indonesian Journal of Islamic Jurisprudence, Economic and Legal Theory, 3(4), 3488–3506. https://doi.org/10.62976/ijijel.v3i4.1513

Rahayu, N. P., Ayuningsih, N., & Aulia, V. (2024). Political Parties and Interest Representation: An Analysis of the Role of Parties in Representing Diverse Groups in Society. Jurnal Multidisiplin Ilmu Akademik, 1(3), 558–569. Https://Doi.Org/10.61722/Jmia.V1i3.1572

Rajagukguk, M., & Djoyosugito, M. A. (2025). Legal Analysis Of The Prosecutor’s Office Performance In Handling Mega Corruption Cases In Indonesia: A Legal Analysis of the Prosecutor's Office's Performance in Handling Mega-Corruption Cases in Indonesia. The Prosecutor Law Review, 3(2). (2025): 43-54. Https://Doi.Org/10.64843/Prolev.V3i2.74

Ramadlan, M. F. S. (2022). Media Politics, Political Media: The Press, the Regime, and Democratic Backsliding. Universitas Brawijaya Press, 63.

Ramdhany, D. M., Budiono, B., Junaedi, D., Ariyanti, J. M., Wiradirja, I. R., & Haspada, D. (2025). Political and Legal Dynamics Influencing Law Enforcement in Indonesia. Themis: Journal of Legal Science, 3(1), 47–56. Https://Doi.Org/10.70437/Themis.V3i1.1402

Rokilah, R. (2020). The Dynamics of Indonesia's Rule of Law: Between Rechtsstaat and Rule of Law: Nurani Hukum., 2(1), 12. Https://Doi.Org/10.51825/Nhk.V2i1.8167

Rozak, A. (2025). Building Democratic Civility: Lessons from the Sociocultural Movements of Cak Nur and Gus Dur. CV Azka Pustaka, 76.

Suhardi, A. (2025). What Can the State Do Against Crony-Style Democracy? Amu Press, 1–484.

Https://Ejournal.Amertamedia.Co.Id/Index.Php/Press/Article/View/535

Tabrozi, D., Umam, M. F., & Rohman, P. K. S. (2025). The Modern State Concept in Guaranteeing Freedom of Expression in Indonesia: A Critical Study of Concept and Practice. 2(1), 199–211. Https://Doi.Org/10.33830/Semnasip.V2i1.6256

The Economisct Intellegene Unit (Eiu). (2024). Indeks Demokrasi 2024 (Hlm. 64). Https://Www.Eiu.Com/N/Campaigns/Democracy-Index-2024/

Transparency International The Global Oalition Against Corroption. (2025). Indeks Persepsi Korupsi. Https://Www.Transparency.Org/En/Cpi/2025/Index/Idn

Tsalitsa Haura Layyina, Mohammad Rafatta Umar, Muhammad Akbar Rahmadhani, Cindy, & Ridwan. (2024). Analysis Of The Political Oligarchy Dpr Of Indonesia During The Jokowi Administration (2019-2024). Arrus Journal Of Social Sciences And Humanities, 4(6), 717–724. Https://Doi.Org/10.35877/Soshum3416

Wjp Rule Of Law Index. (2025). Indonesian Democracy Index (Idi) 2025. Https://Worldjusticeproject.Org/Rule-Of-Law-Index/Global/2025/Indonesia/

Published

2026-09-20

How to Cite

Bistomi, A. Y. ., Hasmaryadi, H., & Fauzi, A. . (2026). Revitalization of The Spirit of Rule of Law: A Critical Reflection on The Dynamics of Democracy in Indonesia. Jurnal Ragam Pengabdian, 3(3), 10027-10043. https://doi.org/10.62710/zg6y4993